D


     I often worried for Sethe throughout the course of this book. She has been through a life of traumatic events. Her childhood spent as a slave without a family, and her older years spent with the haunting if her dead child. Many people go through hard times in their lives, but not many have scratched the surface of Sethe’s misfortune. For any person, time helps heal emotional wounds, but it is necessary to have support whether that be from family or friends. For Sethe Halle was that support in her life. After her “loss” of Halle Sethe turned to baby Suggs, the town leader and mother figure for Sethe. Apart from Baby Suggs, Sethe had the town too. Life seemed to take a turn for the best after her escape. It only took 28 days, for Sethe to lose everything.
     We know well the lengths of Sethe’s love, so it’s difficult to imagine the effects of losing “her best part.” For 18 years Sethe beared the weight of her trauma with no shoulder to lean on. Instead Sethe had to care for her children and deal with a spirit all at the same time. She did all she could, but there are limits to a person’s sanity. Luckily, Paul D found Sethe after 18 years. He was the empathetic friend that Sethe lacked all that time. He helped her with emotional and physical needs which often times are interrelated. Most of all Paul D Showed he was willing to help with her troubles – whether that be a ghost baby or a distrusting daughter. Their time at the carnival showed a new beginning for everyone’s lives, even the townspeople warmed up to the new family.
     It’s no wonder, Sethe felt comfortable enough to share the most haunting part of her history. Paul D couldn’t even bare to look at her the same after she recounted the day in the yard. “You’ve got two feet not four” he told her. Those words cut deeper than he could’ve imagined. After the odyssey she went through only to lose it all in a matter of days, and he saw her as an animal.

Comments

  1. KatieNovember 23, 2019 at 5:50 PM

    Sethe's story definitely is one of loss. As you said, she lost the people she relied on, Halle, Baby Suggs, and Paul D (at least for some time). However, she also lost her children. Sethe makes the decision to try to kill all of her children, and ends up succeeding with Beloved. However, with only one of the family on the "other side", she ends up being separated from her baby except in the somewhat violent ghost form. Then Howard and Bugler end up running away, fearing Sethe from her actions. While trying to do what she saw as protection, the boys only saw a crazy mother. This leaves Sethe only Denver, who is terrified that her mother might kill her. Once Beloved returns, Sethe loses her once again, and Denver starts to leave Sethe as she goes and works. Sethe becomes isolated once again. Paul D does return, but we don't know what happens. Will she be able to survive losing Beloved again?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Adit's BolgNovember 24, 2019 at 10:56 AM

    The story focuses so much on Sethe being a super mom, that when Denver finally leaves the house to become her own individual person, Sethe loses whats makes her who she is. The only one left in in 124 is a parasitic Beloved who feeds off Sethe's guilt and desire to "get her milk to her babies". We can also attribute her wasting away to her role as a mother being depleted. Now that she has nobody to raise, her purpose is gone and so is the point of her continuing to live. Sethe curls up into a ball to die on Baby Suggs' bed and had it not been for Paul D, she may have faded away.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Charlotte EbelNovember 24, 2019 at 9:36 PM

    I agree that Sethe experiences traumatic loss after traumatic loss throughout this novel. However, I think Morrison intentionally took away Sethe's emotional companions as a commentary on slavery and to show the reader how painful her life has been so we can see the murder of Beloved in perspective. Sethe loses Halle because of the heartless cruelty and abuse that Sethe undergoes, which causes Halle to snap emotionally. She loses Baby Suggs because she kills Beloved, but without the emotional trauma from slavery, Sethe would not have killed Beloved. And lastly, she loses Paul D because she killed Beloved. Morrison is showing the reader how, even though slavery is abolished, Sethe is still losing everyone she loves as either a direct or indirect result of slavery.

    ReplyDelete
  4. JoshuaNovember 24, 2019 at 9:45 PM

    I was really annoyed at Paul D, especially his comment about her having two legs not four. Sethe has lost so many people who mattered to her, and Paul is another person on that list. Even if Paul had a right to be upset, calling what she did animalistic isn't accurate. An animal wouldn't be able to feel so strongly, or be thinking about the future enough to kill someone they love more than anything.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Aryan LalwaniNovember 26, 2019 at 9:07 AM

    Sethe is painted as almost a supernatural character, surviving incredible circumstances just to ensure a safe future for her family. Paul D's lack of understanding regarding Sethe's situation demonstrates how different their experiences after Sweet Home have been. Sethe got a taste of freedom for a month before having to experience the consequences of slavery. Paul D doesn't have the right to compare her to an animal based off of her actions, as he cannot comprehend what she's experienced.

    ReplyDelete
  6. SimonNovember 26, 2019 at 5:47 PM

    I feel like Paul D was a little harsh on Sethe with the feet comment. He had also experienced the cruelties of Sweet Home with Schoolteacher in command and knew exactly how terrible it was for Sethe to experience it. I would’ve understood if he was surprised and horrified by her actions, and even if he’d had to leave for a few days to sort through his thoughts, but his complete and total abandonment of her felt far too harsh, and a bit selfish. He could see what was starting to happen from Beloved’s presence, and knew he was one of the only things keeping Sethe going. So, his sudden departure, without even saying goodbye, was just a terrible thing to do, and didn’t quite align with him as a character.

    ReplyDelete
  7. OthnielNovember 26, 2019 at 7:59 PM

    Sethe doesn't have the same support system that many people have today. It is hard to imagine a person having to kill her children to save her children, but we see that she did it out of really strong love. When she tells Paul D this she believes that he will understand how much love it took to do what she did and why she did it, but she doesn't get that. Furthermore, what makes people think that what she did was bad was that fact that she loved them that much anyway. In the book we get from people the it is better to not get attached, but that is not how Sethe works. That is why it is so hard for people to look at what she did as not all bad. I think that nobody giving her the support she needed was bad and things could have been different if people didn't keep cutting her out of their lives. The ending was better that I expected it to be, but it is not easy to say that Sethe got a happy ending.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Eric RothNovember 26, 2019 at 9:24 PM

    This is definitely a very said tale of events for her, losing someone she loved each time she thought that she had finally found someone to "lean on." It really goes to show how sad it is when Paul D leaves her after hearing her story and becoming yet another person who walked out of her life. However, I do think that Paul D's desire to rekindle their relationship near the end of the book shows that he wants to put an end to this cycle and put the past behind them. He wants to give her that support because he knows that he needs some support from her two, as he has had a fair share of traumatic memories. I think Paul D realized his mistake and is trying to make up for it, a very noble thing to do.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Invisible Man Ramblings

     Why is it that Ellison chose to have the narrator reveal the truth of the story at the very end? Well I figure it’s because it’s not supposed to be a great revelation, the narrator’s actually showed us the whole time. I think what makes this novel particularly interesting after reading “Native Son” is the contrast between third and first person. Unlike “Native Son” the narrator chooses specific moments to share with the reader. Like Mr. Mitchell said in class, the narrator writes with an audience in mind. To me that means his accumulative revelations that he shows us are meant to be seen through a lens of current understanding. That might not make sense right away but here’s what I’m trying to say. The story is a first person frame narrative, so there are two layers. In the lens most zoomed in we are just following the narrators actions. In the second lens, we see the big picture. It’s in the second lens that we are meant to view the story because the narrator is t...
Read more

It's an Allusion

     The White Boy Shuffle was a rollercoaster . From the opening scene that began at the end of the story to the apocalyptic ending it was hard to keep up with Beatty’s fast past plotline. I found it interesting that WBS had parallels, if not direct references to books we’ve read this semester. I enjoyed Gunnar as a sassy self-aware narrator, and of course that reminded me of Invisible Man. In fact, I was thinking of Invisible Man   from the first reading. The choice to start the story from the end is taking a page out of Ellison’s writing. Once the story was underway I was reminded of Native Son. Gunnar was like Bigger in a way because of the situations he was placed in. I don’t mean that Gunnar, was placed in the same situations as Bigger, but the effect of Gunnar’s situations are somewhat the equivalent in the modern American society. As readers we saw Gunnar as a social experiment in a way. It was like Beatty was asking us, how do you think a person like Gun...
Read more

Running

For most of the book so far, our narrator has denied his grandfather’s message. Yet the narrator can’t deny he’s been kept running for all his life. As reader’s we first see the narrator on the treadmill during the battle royale scene. The narrator is riding a kayak in the middle of a tsunami. The order of events seem to make no sense, but he flows from one to the next with no question. Only when he figures the blindfold trick does he seem to have some control. That doesn’t last for very long because he still has to face the big guy with whom he can’t cooperate. The narrator doesn’t realize he’s being kept running because this is life as he knows it. At college he’s kept running again by administration. Bledsoe is using the narrator in an attempt to show the “founders” what they want to see. Weirdly enough, Bledsoe is the one running the narrator. Once the narrator is revealed the truth, he grows angry at himself for not realizing and acting in the way he was expected to act. Even ...
Read more